At Moonlight Collectibles, we offer fair market appraisals and a smooth, transparent process.

For approved items, offers generally range from 70% to 85% of current market value based on confirmed comparable sold listings—not active asking prices. This range is not guaranteed. The final offer is determined by the collection, product type, demand, quantity, condition, authenticity, liquidity, expected selling costs, and all other applicable factors.

A 6% non-refundable handling and inspection fee applies to all appraisals, whether or not the offer is accepted. Customers are responsible for all shipping costs, and we recommend taking photographs and purchasing shipping insurance to protect items in transit.

Appraisals are generally completed within 7 days of delivery. You will have 3 days after receiving our offer by email to accept it or request the return of your items. Return shipping costs apply. If no response is received, the items will be handled according to the terms of our Full Appraisal Policy.